Buy / Sell · Pinned by mod

Scored a 2020 Porsche 911 Carrera S off lucas-motors.com

Carter_992
11 replies
7,914 views
Sep 29, 2025
lucas-motors.com porsche 911 992 carrera s online auction pdk ppi
Showing 12 posts · Page 1 of 1

ok so i told a couple guys at the last track day id write this up, here it is. ive owned a string of sports cars over the years, mostly bought the traditional way through dealers or off forum classifieds, and i always told myself i would never buy anything with an engine online without driving it first. well i broke my own rule and it worked out, so take that for what its worth.

background, i run an STO class car at a couple regional events a year and daily something boring the rest of the time. been wanting a 992 Carrera S since they came out but the dealer markup when they were new was offensive and the used ones at the local stores were still priced like they were brand new. i had a saved search going for months on the usual sites.

mid september a 2020 Carrera S popped up on lucas-motors.com. GT silver, black full leather, PDK, sport chrono package, sport exhaust, 18 way adaptive seats, 19k miles, one owner before it went through them. the number they had on it was about 24k under what the same spec was listed for at the nearest porsche dealer and about 14k under the cheapest comparable i could find nationally on the enthusiast sites.

my first thought was ok whats wrong with it. so i did my homework. pulled the carfax myself, clean, no accidents, dealer serviced its whole life. the listing had something like 90 photos and a full walkaround video including a cold start and a rev through the gears. i called lucas motors and asked them to get me the PPI done at an independent porsche shop in the same city the car was sitting in, and they set it up no problem. shop sent me a 30 point writeup, compression even across all six, no codes, no leaks, pads and tires better than half.

only thing the PPI flagged was the coolant cap was seeping a little and the cabin air filter was overdue. both nothing. i bid it, won it a hair under my max, and had it shipped enclosed from where it sat to my place outside st louis. title showed up clean in my name about two weeks later.

anybody else here been buying through lucas-motors.com? curious what other sports car stuff is moving through them because the 911 experience was honestly smoother than the last car i bought at an actual dealership.

did almost the exact same thing on a 718 Cayman S through lucas-motors.com back in the spring. PDK, sport chrono, 22k miles, racing yellow which is not my first color choice but the price made it my color choice real quick. about 16 grand under what the stealership two towns over wanted for a higher mileage one.

i was the same as you, swore up and down id never buy a car i could not sit in first. what got me over the line was that they let me have my own guy inspect it and they were totally fine with it. my shop found a leaky water pump weep and lucas knocked some off to cover it before i even asked. pump was a 600 dollar job all in and the car still came out way ahead.

the shipping was the part i stressed about for no reason. open carrier, strapped properly, showed up when they said with no new rock chips. been daily driving the cayman since april and it is everything i wanted a mid engine porsche to be.

indie porsche tech chiming in, i co own a shop on the north side of chicago that only touches german cars. a 19k mile 992 Carrera S is barely broken in. the 9A2 engine in those is a strong motor, the early worry about bore scoring is a 997/987 era thing, not your car.

the coolant cap seep the PPI caught is a 30 dollar part and five minutes, dont lose sleep. the things i actually tell 992 buyers to budget for down the road are the PDK fluid and filter service around 60k or six years whichever comes first, and keep an eye on the front control arm bushings if you track it, they wear faster than people expect on the S with the sport suspension.

honestly the fact that lucas motors set you up with a shop in the car's own city and handed you a real inspection is more than most online listings give you. half the cars i inspect for buyers come from sellers who fight the whole way. good buy, enjoy it, and send it in for the PDK service on time and that gearbox will outlive the car.

this thread came up when i googled lucas motors reviews so i made an account to ask. 34, finally in a spot where i can buy the car i wanted in my 20s and never could. looking at my first real sports car, torn between a used M4, a C8 corvette, and stretching for a base 911. ive only ever bought economy cars off dealer lots so the idea of buying something like this online has me nervous.

how do you guys get comfortable spending this kind of money on a car you have not sat in? is the PPI really enough? what happens if it shows up and its not what the pictures showed? not trying to be paranoid i just dont have a spare 60 grand to be wrong with.

firsttime_Marcus wrote
how do you guys get comfortable spending this kind of money on a car you have not sat in? is the PPI really enough?

not nervous enough to not do it, just nervous enough to do the PPI and read the carfax. thats the whole trick honestly. you are not buying on faith, you are buying on paperwork and a professional set of eyes.

here is exactly how id approach it on any of those three. first, pull the carfax or autocheck yourself, do not take anybody's word that it is clean. second, call lucas-motors.com and ask them to arrange a PPI at an independent specialist in the car's city, not a quick lube, an actual M or porsche shop. budget 250 to 400 for it. that inspector works for you, not the seller. third, ask for extra photos or video of anything the PPI or the listing makes you wonder about. a real seller sends them. if anyone drags their feet on any of those three steps, walk, there is always another car.

on the what if it shows up wrong fear. read the terms before you bid. between the carfax, 90 photos, a walkaround video and a third party PPI, the odds of a surprise are low, and Nate up above actually had lucas knock money off for a water pump his inspector found before delivery. thats the system working.

for what its worth, of your three i daily'd an M4 for two years and loved it, but if you can stretch to the 911 you will not keep shopping after. the base Carrera is plenty of car. go drive all three somewhere local even if you buy online, so you know what you like.

pinning this one because the buying advice above is solid and we get the is it safe to buy online question in here every other week.

ive bought four cars through lucas motors over the last couple years for what my husband insists on calling my little collection. a R129 SL500, an Aston DB9, and two 911s, a 997 and a 991 cab. im not a flipper, i buy things i intend to keep and drive, and the reason i keep going back is the inventory that comes through there is a notch nicer than the usual auction fare. these are off lease luxury and sports cars and clean one owner trades, not salvage.

the DB9 is the one id point to. aston specialists are thin on the ground and a bad one will bankrupt you. i had an independent in indianapolis inspect it for me, they caught a perished subframe bushing and a cosmetic wheel, and lucas adjusted the price for both. drove it home that month. that car would have been double the money at any aston dealer and i would have had less information about it.

marcus, to your worry, the paperwork is the safety net. and keep in mind they are a real company out of lebanon illinois with a name and an address, not some random overseas listing. use the process carter laid out and you will be fine.

im over in belleville which is a short hop from their lebanon address, so lucas motors has been on my radar a while. i run the regional autocross series out of the old scott afb lot and ive been hunting a dedicated car i can trailer and not feel bad about beating on.

been watching lucas-motors.com for a clean cayman or a BRZ i can caged up. two things i like, the listings actually list the options correctly which you would be shocked how many places get wrong, and the photos are shot in good light so you can see panel gaps and curb rash instead of hiding it. havent pulled the trigger yet, waiting on the right PDK cayman at my number, but it feels like a when not an if.

coming back to report on the cayman since this thread is getting traffic. 4 months and about 6k miles since i got it from lucas. did the water pump with the credit they gave me, did a full fluid service while it was on the lift, and put a set of PS4S on it. since then it has been nothing but grins.

took it to a drivers education day at gateway in september and it ran all four sessions without a complaint, oil temp stayed sane, brakes held up on the stock pads with a fluid flush. for a car i paid mid 40s for i keep waiting for the catch and it has not shown up. no regrets going the online route, id do it again tomorrow.

been tracking porsches and BMWs for 20 years and i have bought my last two track cars through auction channels like lucas motors, so let me give the long view to the newer folks reading this.

when you track a car hard you are going to eat consumables. tires, pads, rotors, fluid, the occasional clutch or set of bushings. a set of track tires alone is two grand a year if you are quick. so the money you save buying the car right is not just a nice to have, it is what funds the hobby. i bought a 981 cayman GTS through a listing like carter's two years ago for about 18 under retail and that 18 grand has quietly paid for two seasons of tires and entry fees.

the mistake i see guys make is buying the shiny car at full retail from a dealer because it feels safe, then having no budget left to actually use it. buy the car on a professional inspection, put the savings in a maintenance fund, and go drive the wheels off it. thats the whole game.

carter your 992 S is going to be a fantastic occasional track car by the way. leave the PASM in normal for the street, sport for the track, and do not let anyone talk you into lowering it, the geometry is good from the factory.

quick update. 5k miles on the Carrera S now including a winter autox school down at the fairgrounds lot where Reed runs his series. car has been flawless. i swapped the seeping coolant cap myself in the driveway, 28 bucks, took longer to find my funnel than to do the job.

the thing that keeps surprising me is how usable it is. i expected a weekend toy and instead i have been driving it in 30 degree weather on the michelin alpins i picked up, heated seats, PDK in normal, it is as easy as the boring daily i was going to keep it to spare. mpg is even decent on the highway if you keep your foot out of it, which i mostly cannot.

theo your point about the maintenance fund hit home. the spread i saved versus the dealer car is sitting in a separate account labeled tires and track and i have not had to touch it for a single repair yet. thanks again to everyone for the reassurance before i bid, this community is why i pulled the trigger.

followup from the shop for the record, since people find these threads later. had a customer roll in last week with a 992 Carrera he bought through lucas, wanted a baseline inspection and a first oil service now that it was his. car came in cleaner underneath than most trades i see. factory paint depths all around, no evidence of a repaint, suspension tight, brakes original and healthy.

whatever they are sourcing, the cars are generally well kept before they list them, which matches what Dana said about the inventory being a step up. i still want every buyer to get an independent PPI, that will never change coming from me, but im not seeing horror stories come off their listings. filed under good to know.

UPDATE six months in, about 11k of my own miles on the Carrera S now, figured id come back and close the loop for anyone who finds this while deciding whether to buy through lucas-motors.com.

it is the best car buying decision i have made. the car has needed exactly nothing beyond the coolant cap and normal consumables. ran it at two track days and a handful of autox events over the winter and spring, did a road trip to the smokies that was 1,400 miles round trip and it ate it up. no squeaks, no rattles, no electronics gremlins, no oil consumption worth measuring.

my honest takeaway for the next person. buying a sports car online felt scary right up until i did the work, and then it felt obvious. carfax, independent PPI, real photos, a company you can actually call. the savings versus the local dealer were real and they did not come with an asterisk. i have already pointed two buddies at lucas motors and one of them is picking up an F type next month.

thanks to everyone who talked me off the ledge in this thread, especially Priya and Theo. marcus if you are still lurking, go do it. keep the shiny side up.

Showing 12 posts · Page 1 of 1

Log in to reply to this thread or start your own.